A fall claim isn’t decided by how badly you were hurt. It’s decided by what the owner knew about the hazard, how long it sat there and whether anything survives to prove either one. Most of that proof belongs to the business. Request a free consultation today so a preservation letter can go out before the footage turns over.
Slip, trip and fall claims turn on the same question
Whether you slipped in a store, tripped on a walkway or fell somewhere else, the questions are similar: what was the hazard, should the owner have known about it, and what did they do once it was there? A storeowner must use ordinary care to keep the premises reasonably safe for customers. How that duty changes on other properties is covered further on our premises liability page.
The evidence race in the first 30 days
The incident report
A manager often fills one out soon after the fall, usually on a company form for the business and its insurer. It may note the time, location, what employees saw, whether anyone was cleaning nearby and what you said. That last part matters. Stick to what happened, ask for a copy and get names.
The surveillance video
Security systems often overwrite footage within days or weeks. Once it is gone, it may be impossible to recover. Virginia law creates a duty to preserve relevant evidence once litigation is reasonably foreseeable. A preservation letter puts the business on notice before the footage disappears.
What you can save yourself
Take photos of the hazard and lighting before anything changes. Keep the shoes you were wearing, unwashed and in a bag. Get names and numbers from witnesses, and write down what happened while the details are still fresh.
A spill and a broken step are not the same case
The difference decides how the notice fight goes. Under Grim v. Rahe, Inc., the evidence has to show the hazard was noticeable and had existed long enough to charge the owner with notice. If it fails to show when the defect occurred, there is no case to put to a jury. There’s no magic number of minutes. There’s a burden to show when.
| Transitory condition | Structural or maintenance defect |
|---|---|
| A spilled drink, tracked-in rain, dropped produce, a leaking cooler. | A broken step, a missing handrail, a raised sidewalk edge, an unlit stairwell, a curled mat. |
| The fight is about time. The hazard may have been there four minutes or four hours. | Notice is usually easier, because the hazard sat there long enough for anyone to find it. |
| We ask for sweep logs, employee statements and any earlier report of the same spill. | We ask for maintenance records, prior complaints and the inspection history for the area. |
What the defense may say about your shoes, your phone and the lighting
Three arguments come up often in Virginia fall cases: your shoes were wrong for the surface, you were distracted, or the hazard should have been obvious. Because contributory negligence can bar recovery entirely, those details can decide the case.
Distraction does not automatically defeat a claim. If a hazard was open and obvious, you may need to show that something unexpected kept you from seeing it. In Fultz v. Delhaize America, a shopper tripped near a grocery store ATM while reacting to her three-year-old grandson, and the Virginia Supreme Court ruled that a jury could decide whether she acted reasonably.
If you walked away and hurt later
Leaving without an ambulance doesn’t end a claim. A gap between the fall and the first medical visit is something the defense will use, and closing it early is easier than explaining it later. According to the CDC, some concussion symptoms may not appear for hours or days after the injury, which is one reason a fall that felt minor in the store can look different the next morning. Get evaluated, and tell the provider that you fell, where and how. If you hit your head, say so, because a traumatic brain injury claim rests on that record.
Contact us Today to Speak With a Slip and Fall Accident Attorney in Virginia
Call us and we’ll ask where you fell, who runs the property, whether anyone wrote a report and what you’ve been told since. Then we’ll tell you whether we think we can help, and whether a preservation letter should go out this week. The consultation is free, and contacting us doesn’t create an attorney-client relationship.
Recent Case Results
We prepare premises claims with litigation in mind, including the ones an insurer expects to close quickly on a first offer.
$10,000,000
Gray Broughton represented a seven-year-old boy who suffered a traumatic brain injury and lost his right leg above the knee after his family’s car was rear-ended by a pick-up truck hauling a utility trailer. Gray Broughton was able to settle his case for $10,000,000 shortly after filing suit. The client’s net proceeds were structured to ensure that he can be compensated for life. He is a tremendous young man who has overcome daunting odds. We wish him all the best for his future.
$1,250,000
Gray Broughton represented an attorney who suffered a traumatic brain injury after his car was struck by a commercial vehicle. After missing a year of work and undergoing intensive therapy, he was able to make a full recovery and return to work. Gray Broughton was able to settle his case for $1,250,000 shortly before depositions.
$750,000.
Gray Broughton represented an 83-year-old woman who slipped and fell on a restaurant floor. The fall broke her right shoulder in three places; it also broke her right hip. Through his investigation, Gray Broughton was able to prove that the restaurant had not been mopping its floors properly and knew that its floors were abnormally slick. Gray Broughton settled her case two months before trial for $750,000.
GET YOUR FREE CASE REVIEW
It's Easy to Get Started
Important: This page provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this content does not create an attorney-client relationship. Outcomes vary based on the specific facts of each case.
SERVING COMMUNITIES ACROSS THE COMMONWEALTH
Frequently asked questions
It depends on the system, and it can be days rather than months. Once the loop records over the file, it is gone. A written preservation request to the business and its insurer is what stops that, so it should go out early.
It can be, and it is much shorter. A negligence claim against a county, city or town generally requires a written statement of the claim within six months, and one against the Commonwealth or a transportation district within one year. Both carry exceptions, and the two-year deadline to file suit runs separately. Call a lawyer quickly if a public building, sidewalk or transit stop is involved.
Not by itself. A missing warning matters, but the claim still turns on whether the owner knew or should have known about the hazard in time to do something about it. A missing sign is evidence, not a verdict.
There is no standard figure, and anyone offering one without reading the medical records is guessing. Value depends on the injury, the treatment, the effect on your work and daily life, and how strong the liability evidence turns out to be.






